Likewise, the possible affinity between the ceangais magicalmystical shamanic practice, as described by the papal nuncio marcus bandinus in mid 17th century, and descriptions of r. Another book, sefer yetzirah is a guide to black magic in judaism. Buber in his reformulation of hasidic tales glossed over this material, and scholems interests lay elsewhere, especially in the realm of mystical theology. A mystical movement within eastern european judaism. Between ecstasy and magic ebook written by moshe idel. Try searching on jstor for other items related to this book. This article is reprinted with permission from essential judaism, published by pocket books. Hasidism, tatars, turks, israel baal shem tov, shamanism 1.
Eye opening book about sexual abuse in the jewish community read it. Hermeneutics, mysticism, and religion idel, moshe on. Moshe idels hasidism between ecstasy and magic albany. Every attempt by modern scholars to present such a body of ideas, however, has failed. Is the link between mysticism and magic new with hasidism or can we find precedents for it in earlier. Between ecstasy and magic, translated into hebrew for schocken press, 2000.
By applying what he calls the panoramic approach, in contrast to the existentialist approach of buber and the historicist approach of scholem, idel has been able to illuminate the phenomenon of hasidism in all its complexity and diversity. Between ecstasy and truth interpretations of greek poetics from homer to longinus stephen halliwell. Between ecstasy and truth stephen halliwell oxford. Idels book has broken new ground in the study of the mystical judaism of eastern europe in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. Historically speaking, a large part of the contents of practical kabbalah predate those of the speculative kabbalah and are not dependent on them. In old worlds, new mirrors idel turns his gaze on figures as diverse as walter benjamin and jacques derrida, franz kafka and franz rosenzweig, arnaldo momigliano and paul celan, abraham heschel and george steiner to reflect on their relationships to judaism in a cosmopolitan, mostly european, context. Book i hasidism and modern man i it is more than fifty years since i began to acquaint the west with that religious movement known as hasidism, which arose in the eighteenth century but extends into our time. Kabbalah and interpretation 2002, and kabbalah and eros 2005. Israel baal shem tov, the founder of hasidism, is proposed.
This might then suggest that a jewish approach to faith, tradition, and history would be fundamentally different from the particular. Contemporary hasidism traces its roots to a single polish folk preacher and itinerant healer, israel ben eliezer, called the baal shem tov master of the good name, or the besht for short. Jan 31, 2017 the kabbalah reception, is a series of books of magic and mysticism. Religious interiorization and the structuring of inner life in early hasidism jerusalem, 2005, pp. See more ideas about books, city of mirrors and this or that questions. He is the author of many studies on kabbalah and hasidism, including kabbalah. The way of man according to the teachings of hasidism. Notably, the first edition of this book had to be printed without the normal haskama, the. Israel baal shem tovs approach to cleaving as dealing predominantly with the oral dimension of the letters, namely, with their sounds while they are articulated in recitation of prayer or torah study. This book, written in the form of traditional midrashimrabbinic dialogues and commentaries on the biblical textintroduces a revised theory of the sefirot, the ten attributes of god first mentioned in sefer yetzirah. Studies in east european jewish mysticism and hasidism on jstor.
Hermeneutics, mysticism, and religion michael fishbane, robert goldenberg, and elliot wolfson, editors hasidism between ecstasy and magic by mosheidel state university of new york press. Gershom scholem, jewish gnosticism, merkabah mysticism and talmudic tradition jewish theological seminary of. Between ecstasy and magic 1995, idel rejected scholems claim that hasidism is a popularization of kabbalistic ideas, and reiterated his own position that kabbalah should not be approached from the perspective of western philosophy. This work is incomparable to anything else and should be required reading for anyone who wants to seriously engage hasidism intellectually and historically. A principal difference between scholem and idel is. State university of new york press, 1995, messianic mystics new haven, conn yale university press, 1998, and most recently, absorbing perfections. State university of new york press, 1995 provides a welcome correction to the doctrinal focus in hasidic studies, but the specific ritual models he describes i. Martin bubers interpretation of hasidism emphasized the power of ecstasy, focus and intention, community, optimism and joy, and sanctifying the mundane through intentional presence. Hasidism is a mystical religious revival movement within judaism, which draws from the kabbalist tradition. Historicism andor phenomenology in the study of jewish. Jun 11, 2018 in our culture, one of the primary ways in which people learn new subjects is by buying a book or two, and reading up. In recent years, the phenomenological and comparative approaches to the study of jewish mysticism have come under criticism. It was called into existence by the charismatic figure israel ben eliezer ca. Jewish magic and superstition is a masterful and utterly fascinating exploration of religious forms that have all but disappeared yet persist in the imagination.
Only one monograph by mendel piekarz is dedicated to polish hasidism between the world wars and during the holocaust. On the satanic nature of the rabbinic kabbalah zaidpub. The miraculous recovery of hasidic communities after the holocaust in israel and the united states and their confrontation with their new surroundings have likewise not been the subject of analysis and discussion. The way of man according to the teachings of hasidism martin buber about the author.
Kabbalah maasit in historical judaism, is a branch of the jewish mystical tradition that concerns the use of magic. Not the least remarkable fact about hasidism is that the 875page book is the work of a team of eight coauthors from three countries. Between ecstasy and magic 1995, absorbing perfections. The volume begins with legends of jewish sorcery and proceeds to discuss beliefs about the evil eye, spirits of the dead, powers of good, the famous legend of the golem, procedures for. Hasidism between ecstasy and magic hasidism t h i s on suny series in judaica. Modes of cleaving to the letters in the teachings of israel. His close study of ecstasy and magic will be essential for all those who are in any way interested in this area. Beginning in the 10th century, jewish mystics and philosophers wrote commentaries on sefer yetzirah, a book about the secrets of creation probably written around the third century.
Used book in good condition used books book binding free ebooks mystic religion wisdom amazon amazons bookbinding. Magic and kabbalah in the book of the responding entity, the solomon goldman. Sefer habahir, a book of unknown authorship,is the most important early kabbalistic work. In old worlds, new mirrors idel turns his gaze on figures as diverse as walter benjamin and. Discussions and analyses informed by a knowledge of literary theory and philosophical aesthetics. Jewish magic and superstition joshua trachtenberg, moshe idel. The book portrays the joy and warmth of life within the community, and the dark secrets hidden behind its enclosed walls. Moshe idel hebrew university of jerusalem academia. At the same time, jewish mystics compiled works of heikhalot literature, an early corpus of texts focused on mystical ascents to heaven. Miles krassen, oberlin college moshe idel is max cooper professor of jewish thought at the hebrew university, jerusalem.
University press, 1994wherein the relationship between mystical experience and interpretation is the guiding theme, from sealed book to open text. Jewish magic and superstition joshua trachtenberg, moshe. This method is not the traditional kabbalistic one. Martin buber was born in vienna in 1878, studied philosophy and the history of art at the university of vienna and of berlin. Numerous and frequentlyupdated resource results are available from this search. Reliable information about the coronavirus covid19 is available from the world health organization current situation, international travel. Moshe idel is the max cooper professor in jewish thought at the hebrew university, jerusalem. However, formatting rules can vary widely between applications and fields of interest or study. Project muse promotes the creation and dissemination of essential humanities and social science resources through collaboration with libraries, publishers, and scholars worldwide. Idels book has broken new ground in the study of the mystical judaism of eastern. Gershom scholem, jewish gnosticism, merkabah mysticism and talmudic tradition jewish. The book is full of brilliant insights concerning the meaning of key concepts and practices in early hasidism. If today, reporting and clarifying, i wish to speak of that work as a whole, this is.
Forged from a partnership between a university press and a library, project muse is a trusted part of the academic and scholarly community it serves. The term hasidic theology should refer to a body of ideas that have characterized hasidic thought from its beginnings in the mideighteenth century to the present, and may be distinguished in a meaningful way from the thought of nonhasidic teachers, both before and during this period and since. He is emeritus max cooper professor in jewish thought at the hebrew university, jerusalem, and a senior researcher at the shalom hartman institute. The kabbalah today, ecstatic prayer as practiced by the baal shem tov and his followers goes beyond merely allowing the illiterate to partake of the joy of worship. These endeavors formed the bridge between early jewish mysticism and its. The first study of its kind, magic, mysticism, and hasidism exp. Between ecstasy and magic suny press, albany, 1994. Dennis, the encyclopedia of jewish myth, magic and mysticism 2007, p. Used book in good condition what others are saying hasidism. This is a big project, and the book could have benefited from a clearer articulation of. The canon has not been strictly defined although the rabbinic consensus names the zohar as the most important volume. Prophecy in the teachings of rabbi kalonymous kalman shapira of piazecna and its renewal. Modes of cleaving to the letters in the teachings of. His successor, rabbi dov ber, the preacher of mezritch, followed his example.
Jewish magical and mystical traditions on the artificial anthropoid, translated into hebrew for schocken press, 1996. Introduction when faced with a particularly weighty problem, the baal shem tov, founder of hasidic judaism, would go to a certain place in the woods, light a sacred. This approach implies a more active type of engagement with the letters than has been assumed in earlier hasidic scholarship, which emphasized. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read hasidism. This superbly crafted book offers intimate stories from hasidic teenagers lives, providing an intriguing twist to a universal theme. Between ecstacy and magic is extremely compelling, rich in the vast erudition idels readers take for granted and full of insights on every page. Hasidism idel, moshe published by state university of new york press idel, moshe. From 1923 to 1933 buber taught jewish philosophy of religion and later the history of religions at the university of frankfurt. Daniel matts anthology is usually the first book i recommend to people beginning to learn kabbalah. It was considered permitted white magic by its practitioners, reserved for the elite, who could separate its spiritual source from qliphoth realms of evil if performed under circumstances that were holy and pure. In effect, what came to be considered practical kabbalah constituted an agglomeration of all the magical practices that developed in judaism from the talmudic period down through the middle ages.
1407 54 611 504 1282 500 740 99 1272 639 1121 907 1029 1331 661 1249 509 530 1505 1114 416 861 497 201 263 534 167 737 1237 1072 415 767 1450 933 1249 277 110 356 964 350 1262 225 1406 175 1314 586 1022